APPENDIX 1a
REGISTRATION SERVICE
BEST VALUE REVIEW IMPROVEMENT PLAN
This improvement plan draws together all of the issues highlighted by the Best Value Review of the Registration Service that was carried out during 2001. The references column identifies for each action the relevant assessment/review exercise(s) and these are further defined in the key below.
Following discussion with the review team, it was agreed that the responsibility for implementation of the whole plan will be assigned to Barbara Botley, the Head of Registration, who will ensure the timely implementation of all actions including those that involve others.
In regard to cost implications, it is envisaged that most of the costs can be contained within the existing revenue budget, although further review of the telecommunications, IT and property implications is needed. Further notes are provided in the column headed `Cost (+/-)/Resource Implications'.
Key to references column: AP Survey Findings from telephone survey of Approved Premises, November 2001 Cust. Survey Findings from customer survey, September 2001 EFQM Report on findings from assessment against the European Foundation for Quality Management model, 11 May 2001 Equal Report Equalities Assessment Report, October 2001 Focus groups Report by Miller Associates, April/May 2001 HMI Report Report of the HM Inspector of Registration, August 2001 LGA Stds Summary of assessment against the Local Government Association Best Practice Guidelines, 28 June 2001 Office Revw Review of all main and sub-district offices and outstations carried out by the Head of Registration Service, December 2001. Option Report Options and Appraisal Report, Recreation and Heritage PRC, 15 November 2001 |
IMPROVEMENT PLAN
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 1 - Restructure the Service into a Single Registration District |
1.1 Single Registration District |
Change to a single registration district |
Currently separated into 10 districts across Hampshire |
Acceptance by members, staff and the Registrar General. |
Prepare plan for changing to a single registration district. Consult with members, staff and other stakeholders as appropriate. Seek approval of the Registrar General. Implement new scheme as appropriate. |
31 Mar 2002 Apr to Sep 2002 30 Nov 2002 1 Apr 2003 |
Cost of consultation exercise. Some efficiency savings from reduced need to take declarations. |
Option Report HMI Report Office Revw |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 2: - Rationalise number of Registration offices |
2.1 Number of Register Offices |
Optimise number of Register Offices |
Some offices are not used or do not meet minimum standards. Assessment of current offices carried out. |
Acceptance by members and the public to proposals for geographic access to the service. |
Assess current status and viability of offices and outstations and make recommendation for change as appropriate. Carry out consultation with members and the public over geographic access to the service. Prepare and implement plan for any changes agreed. |
30 Dec 2002 30 Sep 2002 1 Apr 2003 |
Cost of consultation. Very modest saving on accommo-dation. Impact on Registration budget likely to be cost neutral. |
OptionReport Cust. Survey HMI Report Office Revw |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 3: - Improvements to Buildings and Facilities |
3.1 Physical access |
All Register Offices meet physical access requirements for people with disabilities and parents with young children and pushchairs. |
Not all offices meet required standards. Programme of building works in hand. |
Dependent upon: · outcome of rationalisation of offices review; · financial resources; · priority within building programme. |
Identify building works to meet requirements. Develop programme of improvements. |
31 Mar 2002 Start date: 1 Apr 2002 |
Investment required to meet physical access requirements. |
Focus groups Cust. Survey LGA Stds HMI Report Equal Report |
3.2 Waiting areas and toilets |
Separate waiting areas for: · people registering deaths · wedding clients. Appropriate environmental conditions. |
All customers wait in same area. |
Limitation of buildings. |
Review potential for separate waiting areas at all Register Offices. Investigate improve-ments to environ-mental conditions e.g. · drinks machine · tissues · decorative order · sound proofing · toilet provision |
30 June 2002 |
Cost of building redecorations and refurbish-ments likely to be partially funded from Policy & Resources maintenance budgets. |
Focus groups Cust. Survey LGA Stds HMI Report Equal Report Office Revw |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 3: - Improvements to Buildings and Facilities continued ... |
3.3 Marriage rooms |
Appropriate standard of decoration |
Some offices do not meet customer expectations |
|
Plan and implement programme of redecoration of marriage rooms as appropriate. |
30 June 2002 |
Cost of redecorations |
Cust. Survey LGA Stds |
3.4 Nappy changing facilities |
Nappy changing facilities at all Register offices. |
Not available at all offices. |
Limitation of buildings. |
Review potential for nappy changing facilities at all offices. |
30 June 2002 |
Cost of refurbish-ments |
Focus groups |
3.5 Areas for photographs |
Improvements to locations where photographs can be taken at weddings held at Register Offices |
Poor or no suitable facilities at some Register Offices |
|
Review facilities at Register Offices to see if improvements can be made to areas where photographs can be taken. |
30 June 2002 |
Cost of improve-ments |
Focus groups Cust. Survey |
3.6 Reception facilities |
Improved reception facilities at offices as appropriate |
|
|
Introduce reception staff where possible. Where there are no reception staff, ensure there is adequate signage for customers who need to wait. Review security in reception areas. |
30 June 2002 |
Cost of signage. Nil staff costs. Use of existing staff. |
Focus groups HMI Report |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 3: - Improvements to Buildings and Facilities continued ... |
3.7 External signage |
All offices have adequate external signposting. |
Signage for some offices criticised by customers. |
|
Review signage for all offices and plan improvements as appropriate. Signage must: · Clearly identify office · Display opening hours |
30 June 2002 |
Cost of signage improve-ments |
Cust. Survey LGA Stds HMI Report |
3.8 Record storage |
Appropriate storage conditions for all records. |
Not all current storage meets minimum standards |
No change in legislation |
Implement a programme for central storage of records. |
Subject to change in legisla-tion. |
To be reviewed. |
LGA Stds Option Report HMI Report |
3.9 IT facilities |
All main offices to have adequate computer facilities |
See report on review of offices. |
Financial resource. |
Implement a programme of improvements to IT facilities, e.g. access to IT2000, internet. Review provision of laptops for off-site visits. |
30 Mar 2002 30 Mar 2002 |
Costs depend upon outcome of new single registration district with focus on fewer higher quality offices. |
LGA Stds Option Report |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 4: - Recommend legislative changes to Central Government |
4.1 Less restrictive leglislation |
Changes in legislation |
|
No change |
Recommend appropriate legislative changes to Central Government if these are not covered by the outcome report of the national review. |
Within one month of publica-tion of Govern-ment's Report |
Nil |
Focus groups Option Report |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 5 - Service Development and Performance Management |
5.1 Service Plan for 2002 to 2007 |
5 year Service Plan in place |
Current service plan needs to be updated in the light of Best Value Outcomes |
Service plan will be affected by the outcome of the Government's report on national review. |
Ensure service plan is updated to cover the next 5 years to reflect the requirements of this improvement plan. Ensure there is a process to monitor progress. |
31 Mar 2002 31 Mar 2002 |
Nil |
EFQM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 5 - Service Development and Performance Management continued ... |
5.2 Identification and achievement of local standards |
Achievement of the National Performance Standards for Registration |
Achievement of some national standards confirmed by HM Inspector |
Lack of monitoring process |
Identify and implement local standards. Implement appropriate monitoring processes. Review progress with achievement of standards and communicate with staff. Take appropriate actions to improve performance. Publish service standards and performance results as appropriate. Benchmark against other similar authorities. |
30 June 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM LGA Stds HMI Report |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 5 - Service Development and Performance Management continued ... |
5.3 Competitive-ness |
Compare favourably with other authorities |
Current benchmarking findings suggest good performance compared with others. |
Increased costs. Reduced income. |
Continue to benchmark against other authorities for 2001/2002. |
30 May 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM |
5.4 Effective quality management system |
Implementation of quality management system |
Documented staff handbook. Documented induction procedures. |
None. |
Review registration processes and determine extent of documentation required. Implement appropriate quality management system which documents all relevant policies and procedures, e.g. equalities, etc. Develop a continuity/ recovery plan on how service would be maintained in the event of disaster or other unforeseen circumstance. |
30 Sep 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM LGA Stds Equal Report |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 5 - Service Development and Performance Management continued ... |
5.5 Customer care policy |
Documented policy |
Policy not documented |
None. |
Ensure customer care requirements are identified from relevant sources and documented within quality system. Work towards achievement of Chartermark standards for customer care. |
30 Sep 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM LGA Stds |
5.6 Environmental impacts/ |
Reduction in unwanted environmental impacts |
Provision of leaflets concerning alternatives to disposal nappies at Register offices |
Limited scope for making significant improvements in regard to environmental impact |
Maintain supply of nappies leaflets to birth registrants. Monitor potential for reducing need for staff/customer travel. Review potential for a wider educational/commun-icational role (e.g. at schools, etc.) Keep under review potential for reducing waste. |
Review 30 June 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM |
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 6 - Customer and Stakeholder Feedback |
6.1 Customer satisfaction |
Increase satisfaction levels |
Survey of c.35% of customers carried out in September 2001. |
Dependent upon implementing improvements within this plan. |
Plan and carry out further customer survey in 2002. Include equalities issues. |
30 Sept 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM LGA Stds HMI Report Equal Report |
6.2 Approved premises satisfaction |
Increase satisfaction levels |
Survey carried out November 2001. |
None. |
Review individual comments recorded in 2001 survey. Consider providing an information pack for approved premises. Plan and carry out further survey in 2002. |
30 Nov 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM AP Survey LGA Stds HMI Report |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 6 - Customer and Stakeholder Feedback continued ... |
6.3 Stakeholder satisfaction |
Increase satisfaction levels and improve joint working |
Focus group held with stakeholders (death registrations). Stakeholders involved in challenge group |
None. |
Plan and carry out survey with all major stakeholder groups in 2002. Particularly focus on issues arising from change to single district if approved. Identify means of improving joint working, e.g. GP surgeries. |
30 Sep 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM LGA Stds HMI Report |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 7 - Provision of New Services |
7.1 On-line Registration |
Facility to register births and deaths using the Internet. |
Currently not permitted by legislation |
No change in legislation |
If legislation is changed to permit this, review potential for implementing on-line registration. Investigate electronic links with other agencies. |
31 Mar 2003 |
Investment and running costs of IT & telecommun-ications |
Focus groups Option Report |
7.2 Provision of other new services |
Introduction of new services |
Currently not permitted by legislation |
No change in legislation |
If legislation is changed review new service provision opportunities including: · potential for naming ceremonies · celebrants · extended marriage times · commemorative certificates |
31 Mar 2003 |
Potential costs and savings outlined in Option Appraisal Report. |
Focus groups |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 8 - Service Delivery Improvements |
8.1 Effectiveness of Appointments System |
Improved accessibility to service and reduction in waiting times |
Customer focus group highlighted a minority of cases where appointments over-ran. |
Staff resources. |
Review potential for extending opening hours, e.g. opening earlier, at lunch times, closing later, weekends. Monitor appointment and waiting times across all offices. Review elimination of interruptions during appointments with customers. Review availability of out-of-hours contact numbers. |
1 Apr 2003 31 Mar 2002 1 Apr 2003 Comp-leted. |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
Focus groups Cust. Survey HMI Report LGA Stds |
8.2 Marriage service |
Meeting customer needs for marriage services |
Potential for confusion between wedd-ing parties. Differing standards of music facilities at offices. |
None. |
Monitor and if necessary increase time between weddings. Review need to improve music facilities at offices. |
Review 30 June 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
Focus groups LGA Stds |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 8 - Service Delivery Improvements continued ... |
8.3 Information for customers |
Provision of adequate information for customers |
Findings of review suggest information provision and channels need improvement. |
None. |
Review and improve telecommunications (both systems and staffing). Review and improve · provision of out-of-hours information. · use of answerphones · provision of prior information for people registering a death and couples wanting to marry at approved premises · information about marriage venues. Ensure all brochures and leaflets are maintained up-to-date and are available at relevant access points. |
30 Sep 2002 |
Possible cost of new telephone equipment |
EFQM Focus groups Cust. Survey AP Survey LGA Stds HMI Report |
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 8 - Service Delivery Improvements continued ... |
|
|
|
|
Provide information on best locations for photographs at each office. Introduce maps for customers showing Register office locations. |
|
|
|
8.4 Payment methods |
Introduce facility for payment by credit/debit card |
|
IT and financial procedures. |
Review requirements and implement system for payment by credit/debit card. |
30 June 2002 |
|
Focus groups LGA Stds |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 9 - Staff Development and Involvement |
9.1 Staff perception |
Improved staff perception and understanding of Corporate and management arrangements |
Feedback from some staff suggests a lack of understanding in some areas. |
None. |
Follow up specific issues arising from the HM Inspector' report and the LGA questionnaire survey that indicate lack of understanding of procedures. Consider carrying out a staff perception survey. Include equalities issues. Assess overall satisfaction levels through Staff Personal Develop-ment Reviews. |
30 Sep 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM HM Report LGA Stds Equal Report |
9.2 Effective Pool Deputy System |
Improved effectiveness of pool deputy system |
Not measured |
None. |
Review effectiveness of current system. Arrange annual training day for pool deputies in 2002. |
30 June 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM |
9.3 Staff recruitment |
Staff profile reflects community |
This is not currently achieved. |
|
Review why there is limited interest to vacancies from minority groups. |
31 Mar 2002 |
Nil. |
Equal Report |
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 9 - Staff Development and Involvement continued ... |
9.4 Effective staff induction |
Full implementation of induction process |
Induction process has been documented |
None. |
Review effectiveness of implementation of induction training procedures. Ensure induction includes equalities issues. |
30 June 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM Equal Report |
9.5 IT Skills |
Improved IT Skills |
Majority of staff surveyed identified IT training requirement. |
None. |
Review IT training needs. Plan training provision as appropriate. |
30 June 2002 |
Cost of training requirements. (mainly in-house). |
HMI Report |
9.6 Evaluation of training outcomes |
Improved effectiveness of training |
Measures implemented through training team |
None. |
Review evidence that training outcomes are identified and evaluated. |
31 Mar 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Performance Indicator |
Performance Target |
Current Performance |
Barrier to achieving performance target |
Action |
Target Date |
Cost (+/-) / Resource Implications |
Ref. |
Outcome 10 - Improvements to Communications |
10.1 Internal communication channels |
Effective internal communications |
Some improvements made |
None |
Review communi-cation channels for effectiveness, e.g.: · Team briefings and meetings · Staff feedback · Dissemination of information · Isolated offices · Barriers between offices. |
30 June 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM HMI Report |
10.2 Service information requirements |
Clarification of information requirements Effective provision of information to staff |
Not measured. |
None. |
Devise information strategy in consultation with staff including: · Information/ knowledge requirements and access · Validity of information · Effective information processes · Information sharing, best practice and innovation. |
30 Sep 2002 |
Nil - to be built into normal working procedures. |
EFQM |